Fiction - hardcover; Tuskar Rock; 171 pages; 2009.
There's a lot to be said for short, succinct books, especially if they deliver punches that feel more powerful — and more targeted — than might be achieved by novels of much longer length. It takes a particular skill to craft stories that have been honed to the bare minimum without losing the essence of what makes them special.
Richard Bausch, an American writer, has that rare talent to convey meaning and emotion in a tightly written narrative in which every word has to justify its existence. No surprise, then, that he's largely known as a short story writer.
Peace, first published in 2009 — in the then new Atlantic imprint Tuskar Rock started by Colm Toibin — proves that in the right hands a story doesn't have to be 500 pages long to have an impact. I came away from this one reeling not only with the drama of it, but also the beauty of Bausch's lyrical, stripped-back prose hugely reminiscent at times of all those Irish writers I've come to know and love. On more than one occasion I was reminded of John McGahern — which is high praise indeed.
Dying days of war
The story is set in Italy at the tail end of the Second World War. A group of American soldiers on foot patrol are trying to locate the enemy, which is on the retreat.
The weather is atrocious, the soldiers are exhausted (some are ill with dysentery) and morale is low. When their sergeant commits a war crime — he deliberately shoots an unarmed woman because "she would have shot us all if she could" — those who witness it are too foot-sore and weary to report it. But this one act hangs over all who saw it, haunting their days and their nights.
Three of those witnesses — Marson, Asch and Joyner — are sent on a reconnaissance mission, up a steep mountain with an old Italian man as a guide. What ensues is a difficult journey that is fraught with danger, not only from treacherous terrain and freezing rain and snow, but German snipers hidden in the woods.
Stress and fear
Under these stressful and challenging conditions the soldiers' fears are heightened and yet they cannot forget what they saw the day before, discussing it over and over amongst themselves — was the act justified? should they forget it or report it? are they complicit in the crime? — which only serves to deepen the ructions and tensions between them.
This is a useful device for Bausch to examine each man's character, to fill in their back stories and to explore their own individual morals and beliefs. What emerges is a carefully drawn portrait of a trio of soldiers, fighting on the same side, but all with different prejudices, opinions, fears and foibles.
"You guys are Christians," Asch said. "You believe in an angry God who's interested in payback. Right? 'Vengeance is mine' — all that. Well, we're gonna pay for yesterday. I think we might be paying for it now."
"You're so full of shit," Joyner said. "Let go of it, will you? It's our religion so we're the ones who'll go to hell, not you."
"I'm not even going to answer that," Asch said. "Jesus, Joyner. The way your mind works."
"It's stupid to argue about it here," Marson said.
Creeping sense of unease
As the narrative progresses, the reader begins to share the soldiers' growing sense of unease and paranoia: will they be ambushed by the enemy? Is the Italian man as innocent as he purports to be? Is their mission a complete waste of time?
Peace explores all kinds of issues assorted with war, not least the fine line between courage and fear, and the temptation to behave in ways that would be out of keeping under normal, peace-time circumstances. It highlights the immense task that young, largely immature, men had to endure: Asch and Joyner are barely out of their teens, and Marson, who is their corporal, is only in his mid-20s and yet here they are confronting death — the likelihood of theirs, the prospect of killing others — on a daily basis. Bausch never makes them heroic, but instead shows their innermost struggles to make sense of a world gone mad. There is fear, foreboding and anger on almost every page, but there is also tenderness and heartbreak as each man determines what it is to be good in the face of so much horror.
Despite being less than 180 pages, this is an emotionally intelligent book dealing with weighty themes. It brims with tension and moral complexity but is dotted with lovely moments of quiet reflection that make it an astonishing, curiously gripping and heartfelt read.